Children's & Young Adult Literature

Children's and Young Adult book reviews.

Monday, September 11, 2006

Module 1 Book Review: The Man Who Walked Between the Towers

1. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Gerstein, Mordicai. 2003. THE MAN WHO WALKED BETWEEN THE TOWERS. Brookfield, CT: Roaring Book Press. ISBN 0761328688

2. PLOT SUMMARY
A young man and street performer, Philippe Petit, decides he wants to walk between the two towers being built in New York City. He and his friends sneak into the towers disguised as construction workers with cable and equipment. They spend all night setting up for Philippe’s walk between the towers. As daytime arrives, Philippe begins to walk the cable between the two towers, only to be quickly discovered by the police and eventually arrested. He is sentenced to perform for children in the park, leaving a lasting memory on the children and on the two towers.

3. CRITICAL ANALYSIS
I found this story to be an interesting way to tell an historical account of a not-so-well-known person’s accomplishments. Philippe Petit’s story is quite fascinating. Stories telling of a person’s strong determination to achieve a goal are typically fairly well received. I, however, felt the story could have been told differently, possibly using a different event in Philippe Petit’s life that would show his accomplishments, instead the story focused on Petit’s walk between the Two Towers. I felt the story was pulling on my “heartstrings” a little too much (maybe not intentionally) making me “have” to like the story. After all, how can one not like a story that mentions the World Trade Center, in light of the 9/11 terrorist attacks?

The illustrations are quite beautiful. The pull-out pages are a nice effect to the story and do a great job of conveying a perspective of someone looking in on the event. A reader can feel the overwhelming size of the towers illustrating the magnitude of Philippe Petit’s accomplishment.

As an adult, I did not particularly care for this book. I was finding it very difficult to review this book objectively, though. It was hard not to think about the events that happened on 9/11 at the World Trade Center when seeing an illustration of the two towers. A child, however, might enjoy the story. Many young children do not recall the events of 9/11 and may be able to see the story without any memory associated with the World Trade Center.

4. REVIEW EXCERPT(S)
Caldecott Medal Winner 2004
Boston Globe-Horn Book Award 2004Starred review in PUBLISHERS WEEKLY: “This effectively spare, lyrical account chronicles Philippe Petit's tight rope walk between Manhattan's World Trade Center towers in 1974.”

5. CONNECTIONS
Discuss dare-devils.
Ask children if they have ever set their mind on doing something big and accomplished it or if they know someone who has.
Compare to other Caldecott Medal winners.
Learn more about Philippe Petit, Notre Dame, the Twin Towers, and France.
Learn about street performing.
Demonstrate juggling. Show books on learning how to juggle.
Discuss September 11, 2001 – if reading to an older age group.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home